This is the third edition of our monthly interaction with Gary and again his answers continue to give enormous insight. Info on how to send questions are at the end.
The number of questions was down this month which is good as Gary is very busy. The release of 'Exile' has been pushed back to September 1996 due to the Castle Communications compilation release of covers and the possibility that Gary will be signing with them in the New Year. I don't think the added time Gary has spent answering our questions and getting his WWW site running were solely to blame for the delay :-)
Again some questions have been reworded. I've done this to save duplication, clarify and in some cases, enable us to get more info from Gary. Try to avoid open ended questions or being critical in unconstructive ways. Remember, this is Gary you are addressing, not a record company exec.
Q1. Are you and your brother John very close to each other (i.e. like doing activities together outside of the music business and flying)? Thanks for all the music and inspiration over the years! A1. Yes, we are very close. To ask about activities outside of flying would perhaps be ignoring the very heart of what brings us so closely together in that we both share the same obsessions albeit with a slightly different emphasis. Johnis a professional airline pilot who also flies display aeroplanes and tours with me each year as my keyboard player. I, as you know, am a professional musician who also flies aeroplanes as a hobby. However, we have also passed driving tests for a motorcycle licence I did mine on December 1 '94 and John a few months ago. I have a Yamaha XV535 Virago cruiser and John has a Yamaha Diversion. I'm also going to buy a sportsbike faily soon as the Virago is a pig to keep clean in our wonderful climate and so I'm going to make it a summer bike only.
Q2. Would you consider dying your hair blonde for the next LP photo sessions? A2. No
Q3. Can you clear up something with the Dream Corrosion video? When you sing "Only, mine's broke down" the mic is at your side when 'only' is. Not that I care if it was 'pre' or 're'-recorded, but was it just an accidental slip that was dubbed over later? A3. It certainly wasn't pre-recorded. I did have to red-do one chorus and verse on Are 'Friends' Electric? because the engineer in the mobile allowed the tape to run out before starting the second machine. I had to edit in the music from other parts of the song and then re-sing those parts. It wasn't the bit that you mentioned though so I can only guess that Kipper or Ade was singing along. I've looked at the video and to be honest can't make out who did it. I could go back and dig out the 2" tape but I'm a bit busy at the moment so we'll just have to wonder.
Q4. "Down in the Park" appeared in the 'Urgh a Music War' film. As it is the same recording from the 'Living Ornaments' concerts I assume the entire Sept. 16, 1980 show at Hammersmith exists on film. Would you consider releasing that on video even though it would be similar to Micromusic? Or is that up to Beggars Banquet? A4. I don't know who owns the rights to the music on that film although it certainly isn't me. I'm not sure that the entire concert was recorded either come to think of it. As for it being released in the future I would imagine that if I was to see some more success any old piece of film lying around would suddenly find its way to the public. If it exists of course.
Q5. Are you aware you head-bang at your shows (specifically, during Films)? It surprises me, as much of the appeal of your image during the "early years" was your constraint in moving. I know this may not fit in with your current attitude towards performing or song interpetation, but, I feel it makes the older songs seem a bit too 'rocking' as they seemed top be intended to provoke a doom-laden feeling originally. You do 'ROCK' on some later songs but the Gary Numan most of your fans relate to with the Replicas/Telekon era is very different to the Gary Numan on the later albums. Judging by your fans' reactions at the end of the DC video I'm sure I'm not alone in my views. What's your perspective? A5. I had no idea that 'much of the appeal of the early eighties was my constraint in moving' and I'm very sad to hear that you think that is the case. My songs are intended to provoke whatever I want to provoke, then and now, and if I feel like changing that original feel with a different version of the same song then I feel that is my right. It's hard enough having to give so much control of my music over to record companies as it is without having my very movement on stage dictated to me as well. I find it amazing that I should be expected to move in a certain way because of the year that a song was recorded in. How boring it would be for me, and surely for the audience, if I were to move the same way, to the same song, year after year after year. If that is genuinely how you and others feel I can only suggest, and I honestly don't mean to take the piss, that you buy an early video and settle for that. I still stay fairly static during songs like 'Down In The Park', whenever I do it that is, but I thought the current live version of 'Films' had a quite awesome amount of energy in it and to stand still would have gone against every molecule in my body that was crying out to be thrashed up and down. Regarding the people talking at the end of the Dream Corrosion video I again don't think I see what you appear to see. The people seemed to have enjoyed the show very much, including the choice of songs and the performance in general. I'm sure about that because I edited the film with my friend Nicky Robson and I would not have used anything that was less than flattering now would I? To be honest nobody said anything negative at all so we just picked the most bubbly personalities.
Q6. I seem to be the ONLY Numanoid on Earth who recognizes the difference between the single version and the video version of I Die: You Die. I know it was released as a limited white label A-side but I would really like to see it released on CD. Could you urge BB to use it on any future BB Numan CD? releases? It could have been included on the recent UK re-issues of '93. Do you have to get BB's permission to include alt. versions of BB tracks on the IMAGES recordings? A6. The only one including me it would seem as I wasn't aware of the video being different either. I've also never heard of a limited white label release but Beggars may have done so without telling me I suppose. I'll urge them if I remember the next time I talk to them which is about once every 3 or 4 years at the moment. I don't actually ask permission as the numbers are so low on 'Images' that nobody cares.
Q7. I was wondering if you are religious at all or what exactly your views on religion and God are? You make a lot of references to God in your lyrics and I was very curious about this. I would like to also add that I have been a loyal fan of yours since 1979 and am glad that you makes the music that you do. To me you have a sound all your own and are in a class by yourself. I look forward to every album you make. A7. I am not religious, quite the opposite. It would seem, particularly at the moment, that in certain countries to deny having faith is virtually to admit to being a woshipper of the devil. Such is the fear, hate and hostility created by the believers of this so called all forgiving God. I worship nothing. Not a good lie nor a dark one. If nature is proof of God's amazing creation then I have truly seen the light, and the light is black. Nature is genius at its most cruel and savage. No benevolent God could have come up with such an outrage. I'm often told that 'ours is not to reason why'. But surely, if you believe, then you must also believe that our ability to question is a God given ability. If we are not to use such an ability, given to us by God, then surely, in effect, we deny part of God's creation. Does anyone honestly believe that little Gary Numan, asking a few questions here on this small island, can honestly be a threat to a being that created the entire Universe in just six days? Of course not. Why then do these devout believers feel so much danger from a simple question. Why is violence so much a part of following 'the rightous path'. I don't understand the fanatacism and damage that such 'goodness' creates. I'm told that we all have a choice in what path we follow. Good or evil. In England a while ago a small baby boy was horrifically tortured and then cut up by two other, slightly older children. Explain to me the choice that poor child had. Show me the mercy of God. He suffered a long, bloody, screaming, agonising death. If the rest of the world was a haven of piece and tranquility, which sadly it is not, that one atrocity alone would convince me that God does not exist. At least not in the way the church and its followers would have us believe. It seems that I could be in danger of ruining my newly reborn career, in certain parts of the world, before it has even begun just by saying these things, by upsetting the self proclaimed rightous majority. I watch it all with a growing sense of doom and forboding and remain thankful that I live in England. The new album 'Exile', without me intending it when I began, has become almost entirely focused on my views about this subject. The following lyric is a small section from a new song called 'Prophecy' which kind of illustrates my point: We are deceived Valhalla is falling We are betrayed We are lost and forsaken. He's sold the World Sold us all to the hunger The body of Christ Is as black as his soul. The word of the Lord Is the lie of your Father This mortal sin Is a voice of shame Look at the storm Like a dying apostle Cruel and divine Like the ghost of man. If this offends anyone I don't care. If people turn away from me because this is how I feel. I don't care.
I'm a mechanical engineer who works on aircraft support equipment. Being a mechanical engineer, I am particularly partial to your song "Engineers". Q8. How did you end up being a member of an acrobtic flying team? A8. When I bought my Harvard aeroplane in 1984 I was approached and invited to join a group of other Harvard owners simply to fly around together. That casual arrangement, over a few years, grew into a highly skilled formation team. I also fell in love with aerobatics and so I just merged the two disciplines into one display item.
Q9. What do you like and dislike about the Harvard? What other airfaft have you flown? A9. It has a number of things that are less than an ideal. The roll rate is poor, it's underpowered, any number of flaws really but that's what makes it what it is. It is a piece of aviation history so the flaws are actually part of the pleasure of flying such a machine.
Q10. Any chance of doing a display in the USA some day? A10. It would be nice. I would need someone to lend me their aeroplane though as I couldn't really bring mine over. Good luck to you and happy flying.
Q11. Hello, Gary! I'm one of your US fans who's planning a trip across the pond to see you on your 1996 tour next spring. I was wondering if you might considering offering for sale, at the concert souvenir tables, some of the fan club CDs, such as Radial Pair and the Babylon series, as they're pretty damn hard to come by over here. If any copies are left over by April, you can be sure I'll pick them up. And of course I'll look forward to meeting you at the post-gig hotel party. A11. I doubt that we will make them available at the concerts as we have to specialise a little on tour but they are all available on the NuWORLD web site. NuWORLD is now on-line for test and feedback purposes, prior to its official start day of January 1 1996. You can look in on it and order stuff if you wish by browsing http://www.numan.co.uk Hopefully, a mirror site courtesy of Joey Lindstrom will be operating on the other side of the ocean soon for non Europeans.
Q12. Not so much a question as a comment, or a piece of information. A few weeks ago you said selecting a set list was tough because you often didn't really know what fans wanted to hear. It so happens I conducted a poll on this digest a few months back, and here are the 4 most popular song choices submitted by folks on the net: Crash; Telekon; The Aircrash Bureau; The Joy Circuit. A12.Interesting that 3 of them are from the Telekon album considering I've written over 300 songs. Also interesting when I look back and remember that the Telekon album, at the time, sold very much less than Replicas and Pleasure Principle. How opinions seem to change over the years and how difficult it makes it for me to take any notice of them at times. A top 30 would be VERY interesting.
I've been a fan since 1980. First off I would like to thank you, Gary for contributing so much to my life and also for taking the time out of your busy schedule to answer fans' questions. Q13a. My question is have you ever considered making a CD-Rom. Even if it was only offered to your fanclub members I would think it would be very successful. I have a friend in California who worked on the CD-Rom for the Residents titled Gingerbread Man and as soon as I saw it I thought this would be great for Numan. I hope you consider it. Thank you for everything,and,
Michel Lafontaine (102162.2077@compuserve.com) of Montreal, Quebec, Canada asks:
Q13b. Have you given any thoughts on putting out a CD rom like others have done recently ? (Again if there were no constraints) A13a and b. I have looked at it, but not with any great intention of actually doing one. It seems to me that they require a fair degree of money to produce and to make one for the fan club only would in no way get that money back. As an example I was asked by the fan club members for years, almost 12 in fact, to put out a Numan calander. This year we did just that and sold less than 450 in total. That's a very small percentage of fan club members and I will definitely NOT be making another one. It cost me a lot of money, a LOT of money, and a CD-Rom would appear to have a much larger potential for eating my wallet than a calander. If things improve in the future I would certainly love to have a go at doing one for the creative vibe of it.
Q14. Do you ever intend to do a concert in Ireland? There are still quite a number of your fans interested in seeing you in concert here. Thanks for many years of excellent Music. A14. It depends on how the career goes. Success brings with it the financial security of being able to travel without taking out a second mortgage. Touring in England costs me in excess of =A35,000 a day now, and that is after years of fine tuning our operation. In the past it has been as much as =A330,000 a day. As you know, or may do, in the early days I regularly lost a small fortune every time I went out on tour. I can't do that anymore, I don't sell enough records to make up for that kind of loss, so I have to be very careful about where I play. Hopefully, if the new record deal comes along, that situation will change. I hope so.
Q15. Could you tell us a bit about Richard Beasley. He seems to be the quiet man of the current band and doesn't get the coverage that Kipper, Ade, John etc seem to get. A15. Richard Beasley is 32 years old I think. I see him regularly, as I do Ade Orange. Richard now lives near Richmond, Surrey, which is kind of West London although not officially. He is married, although seperated, awaiting a divorce. I don't really know much more apart from the fact that he is a brilliant drummer and great fun on tour.
Q16. You used to say that each tour was better than the last. Is this still the case or is there a particular tour you look back on and say "That's the one" ? A16. The Dream Corrosion tour was my favourite and the OMD support that followed it strangely enough.
Q17. In what ways are you looking to make Exile different to Sacrifice ? A17. Heavier percussion/drums. More anthemic. Very strong and heavy lyrics. A more raw and aggressive guitar style (on songs that have guitar that is). Thanks for all the good times over the years. Don't forget us here in Ireland come tour time and don't tell anyone but I quite like Outland as well.
Hi Gary... When I was growing up as a gay kid (I was 11 in 1979), your lyrics on some songs such as Jo The Waiter, etc etc, and various reasonably positive "gay-friendly" lyrics in other songs helped me a great deal to come to terms with myself (And Everyday I Die helped me come to terms with something else, but lets not go into that !!) Well, I realise youre not gay, but all the same, thanks so much for helping me come through my teenage turmoil! Anyway, when I saw you were playing the G.A.Y. club in London last year I was thrilled ! I had assumed that after your support of the extremely homophobic conservative party in the 80s that a gay club was the last place you would play ! Anyway... Q18. I realise you're not a big fan of discussing politics, but could you give me an idea on where you stand politically, and what your views on the gay age of consent are ? (Currently its 18 for gay men and 16 for everyone else...) A18. First of all I supported the Conservative Party, many years ago now, for their stance on things other than homosexuality, which I believe was the case for most of the non Gay community of Great Britain. Please don't make the slightly naive mistake of believing that all Conservative voters are, are were, anti gay. I'm not that inclined to talk about where I stand politically actually. I'm anti socialist and always will be, but then Labour appears to be anti Socialist as well at the moment doesn't it? I don't really stand anywhere. The Conservatives are in a mess, Labour changes it's tune simply to get into office which doesn't exactly inspire belief or confidence and the others are a waste of space anyway. I feel that the gay age of consent should be the same as the non gay age of consent. It would seem that the government feel that any gay feelings that young people may have may have been 'grown out of' by the age of 18 which I think is insulting and not particularly intelligent. Let people experiment, safely, with who or whatever consents to experiment with them and forget about the 'age of consent' law altogether.
Q19. Can you delve that far back in your memory and fill in the questions marks? title on bootleg title as announced on recording ---------------- ------------------------------- Motherless Faces ? Boys same Blue Eyes same You Don't Know Me ? My Shadow In Vain same Me My Head same That's Too Bad same Basic J same Do Your Best (Friends) same Oh! Didn't I Say same I'm A Poseur same Kill Sir Joy Pure Saint Joy A19. Not all of them. Motherless faces was actually called 'Positive Thinking' You Don't Know Me could be correct. Kill Sir Joy was called Kill St Joy after the owner of the Roxy Club, a man called Kevin St John, wanted certain unsavoury things from me.
Q20. Can you remember anything about the Live At The Roxy '78/Vortex '78 7" single bootleg? The tracks listed for this one are: White Light - White Heat b/w Bunch Of Stiffs and "Bunch Of Stiffs" is listed as being by Mean Street with you on guitar and backing vocals. This single supposedly being from '78 leaves me with questions as well as whether the band was really Mean Street then. I can vouch for the single itself since I have it, but I cannot vouch for what it actually contains. Can you help me with these very "early" questions? A20. Again not much. I didn't ever play with Mean Street and so I'm definitely not on the Bunch Of Stiffs track. Don't know about the White Light, White Heat song though.
Q21. Gary, I really enjoyed listening to the Babylon CDs. In particular, I found "Tribal" to be very interesting. I was amazed at how different the non-chorus parts sounded to the final version, "Call Out The Dogs." I was wondering if you have lots of other early versions of songs and if so, if you have any plans on releasing them in the future? A21. I've found one or two bits that are simply unfinished songs but no other early versions of things you may know. Future plans for the bits are uncertain.
Q22. On an the bootleg "Live At The Roxy 1979," you and the old Tubeway Army band played a number of early punk songs that sounded great but I have never heard of anywhere else (e.g. "I'm A Poser," "Pure St. Joy," "Motherless Faces," "Boys," "You Don't Know Me," and "Me, My Head"). Can you recall (and I realise this was all a *long* time ago) if you recorded studio versions of the "Live At The Roxy 1979" songs along with all the others which would later appear on _Tubeway Army_, _The Plan_ and all the early singles? If you did, is it reasonable to assume that Beggar's Banquet has yet to release all of the early material? A22. Don't think so. I'm quite sure that everything that Beggars had recorded of my early stuff has now seen the light of day.
Q23. I have many favourite songs of yours, but one of the most treasured is the song "Cry, The Clock Said." Of all the songs you have ever written, this one still stands out of the crowd as being distinctly unique, with its long intro, haunting violin sounds by Nash the Slash, creative yet very personal lyrics, and overall feel of melancholy mixed with contemplation. I was hoping you could say a few things about this song, from what inspired you to write it as you did to how you feel about it today, 15 years later. Incidentially, I think this song would sound great live with the new _Sacrifice_ style and hope you consider using it. A23. The Dance album had a slightly self indulgent feel to it all the way through so I was quite happy to let the 'Cry, The Clock Said' song have such a long intro. I don't think I had any special concept behind it other than that's how it felt it should go at the time. A long, slow build. It was concerned, as much of my early stuff was, with people that I had felt had let me down. I can't remember much more. I'd forgotten that Nash was even on it. Thanks for answering these questions and putting out such great music year after year! Brian Hammond
Dear Gary, Let me first of all begin by thanking you profusely for the many years of great music. Most of my teen years were spent listening almost exclusively to your albums. Q24. It is patently obvious that you have never received your fair share of credit for the innovative and refreshing musical styles you have pioneered, and continue to pioneer. Instead, when the music press has not been hurling abuse at you and your music, they have completely ignored your significant musical contributions. What I would like to ask you is what you personally feel the reason is for such hostile reactions towards you, while many groups with little or no talent receive a disproportionate amount of exposure. I am more interested in your opinion as to WHY you are subjected to this negativity, rather than a list of who put you down and when. A24. Hard to say without asking each and every person why they wrote what they did. I do believe that a group mentality exists that make certain people fashionable to be 'in' to and others not. It takes a brave man or woman in a newspaper/magazine office to praise someone that is 'not' favoured. It may even be that the majority of people in that office actually do like that person or band but won't admit to it for fear of being seen as ou of touch perhaps. I don't know for sure but that may have something to do with some of it. At the moment I seem to be enjoying the early stirrings of my first ever taste of being 'in'.
Q25. I read a while ago that you were once forced to land in Vishakapatnam, in India, when you were flying around in the mid-80s, and that you were actaully detained there for a few days while the Indian authorities determined whether you were involved in subversive activities. Being Indian, I would be very interested to hear about what actually happened, how you were treated there, and about your general impressions of the country. You can be honest, as I won't take any offense if the incident didn't leave you with particularly fond memories. A25. We made an emergency landing in Vishakhapatnam due to a rough running engine in my Cessna. We were then arrested, unofficially, and kept under house arrest for 4 days while they decided whether we were spies, smugglers or just adventurers. I thought they treated us very badly, bursting into our rooms in the early hours of the morning demanding that we tell them things we didn't know and that we be 'co-operative', whatever that meant. They confiscated our passports, would only let us travel to a telex machine under armed guard and exposed all of our film, movie and 35mm still, that we had been shootng for a BBC program about our round the world flight. Vishakhapatnam was, without meaning to be rude, a complete pighole. However the people throughout India, outside of officialdom, were excellent and were some of the happiest, friendliest people that I have ever met. The country is vast and impoverished apart from the tiny few of great wealth. While I was in Calcutta I was befriended by a boy who gave me a great story about having to support his entire family and that all he needed was his own rickshaw and he could then be a wealthy man. I bought him the rickshaw business before I left. I would love to know if he actually made anything out of it or whether he was just conning me.
Q26. Which neighborhood of Los Angeles did you live in back in 1982? Can you remember the street or address (no I won't be making a pilgrimage :-) ? A26. I lived at the apartments at the top of Horn Avenue, off Sunset if memory still holds, and I had a house that i got to by driving up Doheny something or other. I can't remember the address or the name of the road that it was on only that it was brilliant, had its own swimming pool and was on the top of a hill that overlooked the entire city of Los Angeles. Loved it.
To begin I'd just want to say thanks for all the joy you've provided to us all over the years. Now for the questions: Q27. You've explored violins,the fretless bass,the sax and a few other stuff; are there any instruments you would like to use or feature if you had no constraints whatsoever ? A27. Not really. I'm more interested in sound than in instruments so it will depend on what 'sounds' interest me in the future. That may lead me towards a certain insrument. Nothing in mind at the moment though.
Q28. Most of your records have your picture on them except for a few singles, why is that as opposed to an artwork of some kind ? I'd love to see a contest where the fans could submit ideas for the next sleeve design...Subject to your approval of course ! A28. I actually prefer to design my own sleeves thanks. I hadn't really thought about it but I suppose the main reasons for having my picture on the sleeves is to introduce new images for one thing, it's easier to slap on a gppd steely eyes piccy than figure out some clever artwork and finally i would have to confess to ego.
Greetings: I have but one simple question, and this is based on the fact that we do all kinds of reviews, votes, wish lists, etc. Q29. "Do you have any questions you would like to ask of us? Given the amount of time and effort you put into responding to ours, it seems only fair we provide you with some knowledge you might be interested in (assuming there is any)." Trent (in a still unified country - for now) A29. I have a vast amount, mainly to people who complain and all of them to individuals. Somethings have to be done face to face.
Gary, I can speak for everyone when I say that we are all very excited to see what tracks you decide to play next tour and put on the next live CD. Q30. I was wondering if you could give us an idea of any particular tunes you have in mind to rehearse, whether they be songs you've never done or something you haven't done for quite a while? A30. Quite a few that I've not done before for sure. Some from way back like 'Sleep By Windows' are being considered. I'm a long way from really getting down to it and deciding though. The Exile album going back has thrown a bit of a spanner in the works as well.
Q31. When you performed "My Shadow in Vain" on stage from 1984-1988, you changed most of the verses lyrically. Why was that? A31. Forgot the words. I wrote that song when I was about 18 so no wonder I struggle with that one. I can't remember the words to the song I just wrote. Before I began writing these answers I wrote the lyric and recorded a vocal for a new song called 'An Alien Cure'. It took about an hour or so to decide just how to sing it, trying various styles, and I still couldn't remember the words. I've got no chance on stage. Strange thing is I can remember a mass of speeds, oil pressure and temperature limits for the aeroplane, all manner of techy type procedures and numbers but I cannot remember my own phone number after having it for years and I can't remember my own lyrics.
Q32. Any chances you may re-enter another character or image for future albums or are those days long gone? A32. Maybe. To be absolutely honest it's my age that inhibits me from doing that kind of thing now. It doesn't feel right anymore. ---- Thanks as always, Gary Numan.
Send your questions via email to Derek Langsford [dlangs@sunstroke.sdsu.edu] with a subject line of:
Gary's Qs
Please include your real name and the town/city, county/province/state and country where you are located. Please follow these directions carefully and don't post your questions to the Digest as that means more work for me :-(
I reserve the right to delete and edit questions for content or length.
Thanks to all for taking part,
Derek