The captions on the Charlotte shows, which appear to indicate Gary's actual speech at the time, are purely conjectural and were written by Joey Lindstrom one night while he was sitting home alone and the power went out.
Charlotte
"Yes, I like you too."
"Me nose itches. I think
I'll scratch it on this thing..."
"OI! YOU! YEAH, YOU!"
"Here in my... shite, forgot the words again!"
"Excuse me, did you drop that?"
Atlanta
Tim meets his idol...
...and asks him for an autograph...
...which he later has tattooed on permanently...
...as did friend David Batchelder.